April 4-10, 2014
What percentage of the new medical graduates from the growing number of medical colleges will stay in?Nepal? Of those that stay in?Nepal, what demographic features characterises them versus those that leave? These were questions that Dr Mark Zimmerman and his colleagues set out to find in a study (based primarily on the findings of Nepal’s oldest medical college, Institute of Medicine ( IOM), Maharajgunj)?published in the Aug 14, 2012??issue of the British Medical Journal.
These questions are obviously important for policy makers in ?Nepal?to help determine which kind of medical graduates will stay home and render their services to Nepali society. Previous studies in high income countries have shown that medical graduates with rural backgrounds are more likely to work in rural locations. So, one of the question was, would the study from ?Nepal?also replicate this finding?
The authors tracked 710 graduate doctors from the first 22 classes (1983-2004) of IOM to their current practice locations. They analysed seven factors including gender, age entering medical school, place of birth, place of high school, type of pre-medical education, and academic rank. Results showed that from these 22 classes, roughly a third each were working in?Nepal’s rural district (27 per cent), in?Kathmandu (37 per cent) and??abroad (36 per cent). Of those working abroad, 188 (73 per cent) were in the?United States.
The fascinating finding was that those who had worked as paramedics prior to medical school??(for example as health assistants) were twice as likely to be working in Nepal and 3.5 times as likely to be in rural Nepal compared to those graduates who only had a college science background. And in keeping with studies from high income countries, a rural birthplace was also independently associated with working in rural?Nepal. Entrance to medical college at an older age also made it more likely that the doctor would work in rural areas.
Clearly the study had limitations. Only one medical school was taken into consideration, and it was limited to the time period of 1983, the first graduating IOM class, to 2004. The data is therefore ten years old now during which time many medical schools have mushroomed and many students have graduated. Nonetheless, this is a painstakingly carried out baseline study with important, unique findings Sadly?India, with over a population over 1 billion and a long track record of many English medium medical colleges, does not seem to have published any recent studies in good quality, peer-reviewed journals tracking its medical students as this study has done. So in a sense, this study from?Nepal?has filled an important void, and the authors are to be commended.??
However, the results of the study give us cause for thought. The IOM which admitted most medical students with paramedic background stopped doing this for unclear reasons and clearly reversed its procedure and limited its admissions to generally very young doctors with a science background.
Based on the findings of this study, the unnecessary shift has been counterproductive to efforts to get doctors to stay. There are obvious exceptions to this rule, and one of them is young Dr Amogh Basnyat who recently graduated from IOM and works in rural Kalikot District Hospital in western Nepal as a MD GP providing vital medical service (including performing the life-saving Caesarian sections when necessary) in this remote area. And there is also the new Patan Academy of Health Sciences,?which through a series of elaborate tests and interviews focuses on choosing potential medical students who are truly motivated to work in rural settings.??
Leave a Reply